Sunday, July 4, 2010

The Lost America

Burke's Corner on The Lost America. He reminds us of a more settled, ordered and peaceable polity prior to the runup to 1776, which was less aggressive and less populist than the tradition that ensued after the revolution.

Lynching
The lynching of an American Tory

James Hall on a previous diatribe against present day American Tories, proves this point with this statement:

A real conservative is a revolutionary in the pursuit of individual rights and an advocate of constitutional protections and limited government.

In the American tradition, this anti-Burkean statement is probably on the mark as it relates to so many of today's "conservative" talk shows in the United States. The voice of Russell Kirk is of an older American tradition that doesn't see the country's starting point in the year 1776, but it is a small minority and cannot be heard under the thunderclap of Republican America.

We continuously hear what was gained by America on Independence Day. We rarely hear what was lost when about a quarter of the colonist population was persecuted for their American loyalist beliefs. But heh, Happy Independence Day all the same to our American (who represent the majority of our readers) friends.

4 comments:

  1. As one of those American readers (actually I'm technically a contributor though I never seem to post here) and an unreconstructed Tory/Loyalist, I find it difficult to be "Happy" today. Thanks for the "Burke's Corner" link though.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I very rarely post here as well, but folow your blog closely. I am saluting Independence Day out of respect, not out of happiness. Given that the United States will never become a loyalist kingdom with a royal family, I would encourage you to emigrate long enough to become one of Her Majesty's subjects in one of her many realms or outposts. You would not even have to relinquish your American citizenship, for it is a part of who you are, unfulfilled as that may be for you. If you long for it, it can be yours too.

    ReplyDelete
  3. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Believe me, I've fantasised about it. It's not any sentimental attachment to American citizenship that keeps me in the US, but rather more mundane obstacles such as professional and financial considerations, as well as family and friends. Still, perhaps someday...

    ReplyDelete